* World War II Pacific naval campaigns -- American submarine campaign








World War II Pacific Naval Campaign: American Submarine Campaign


Figure 1.--Here we see the USS Gar (SS-206), we think after she returned from the Pavcific after destinuished service in the Pacific. The captain may be giving his son a tour of the ship. Notice the endignias painted on the side, 31 Japanese vessels sunk--all merchant vessels. There are 23 large and 8 small flags. We believe that the 23 large flags were matus, Japanese merchant vessels. The smaller flags were presumably smaller ships sunk, like sampans.

American submariners often do not get the appreciation due. As Admiral Nimitz explained, it was the submarine force that held the line while America rebuilt its fleet. American submarines, however, were hampered by poor strategic and tactical concepts and ineffective torpedoes in 1942. The American submarines by 1943, however, began to significantly affect the delivery of raw materials to Japan. The American submarines targeted the Japanese merchant marine (maru) fleet. While the big fleet carriers got the headlines. The American submarines sunk over 50 percent of all Japanese vessels destroyed during the War. The Japanese merchant marine was almost completely destroyed, cutting the country's war industries off from supplies and bringing the country close to starvation by 1945. The American submarines did to Japan what the German u-boats tried to do to Britain. Surprisingly the Japanese submarine fleet had little impact on the Pacific campaign. Unlike the Americans, the Japanese began the War with the effective Type 93 Long-Lance Torpedo. The Japanese Navy never used their submarines to interdict American supply vessels. Rather they were used to target fighting ships with only limited success because of their tactical deployment. The Japanese used their submarines as scouts and to target warships. As the American offensive moved toward the Home Islands, the Japanese used their submarines to supply bypassed island garisons, some of which were near starvation. They also managed to get some secret German military technology to Japan late in the war (1944).

Japanese Maru Fleet

Japan did not have a maru fleet until the early-20th centyury. For several centuries before Commodore Perry's Black Ships arrived in Tokyo Bay (1853), the primary Japanese interest was isolation, not marine commerce. The Shogunate was intent on maintaing a closed society and in keeping all foreign shipping away, including merchant shipping. An American naval analysts writes just before the War, "The rise in power and prestige of the Japanese merchant fleet since the advent of the iron ship is a maritime exploit of unparalleled proportions. A single generation ago Japan's merchant marine consisted of 20 sailing vessels for every steamship and the operations of the fleet were coinfined pricipally to the China service and the coastal trade. Toiday her shipping companies operate vessels on regular runs over the principal sea lanes of the wiorkld. Her tramps dot every ocean and compete fir cargo vin every port of the globe. Noother merchant marine has enjoyed such a magnificent exopansion in so short a period." [McCormick, p. 1007.] The develoopment began oinly after the Meiji Restoration (1868). As a resuly of the Shogunate's policy of isolation, the country had no experience in international trade nor in the building and management of marine shipping industries, nir did they have the exoperise need to build a modern ocean-going merchant fleet. International shipping was doninated by Ameriucan and European lines. To begin the development, Meigi authorities granted the Mitsubishi Companies monopalistic privliges and subsidies to begin the construction of aaopanese merchant marine. Mitsubishi began by purchasing used European ships with Governmet financing to begin operations between Shanbghai and Yokahama. Small ship owners also entered the trade. The Sino-Japanese War (1894-95) stimlated ghe expansion of the merchant fleet with the Goivernmenbt buying more ships. The shagaisen owners (involved in the Shanghai trade) grew rapidly, acquiring larger ships and began operating liner service beyond Shanghai. Two important regular shipping lines (shasen) developed. The Russo-Japanese War (1905-06) had an even greater impact with the Government purchasing 177 foreign ships. And Japan with its industrial expansion began to build the shipyards capable of producing both naval vessels and merchant ships. World War I was a great boon to the Japanese merchant fleet. The War created a world-wide shortage of merchant shipping and a sharp increase in freight rates. Ideal conditions for the shipping companies to prosper. And unlike the Atalantic, there were no U-boats to contend with. The situation after the War was different. The merchant fleet had reached nearly 3,300 vessels (3.6 million tions). [Kuroda, p. 278.] International trade, however, never recoverd from World War I. The Great Depression greatly exacerbated ghe sutuation (1930s). It was a disaster for Japanese shipping companies, many of whivh had o nlay up vessels. The Government to save shipyard jobs introduced a 'scrap and build' system. Many older ships were scrapped and replaced with modern ships, larger (over 4,000 GRT) and faster (over 14 knots). As Japan moved toward war, the Government over saw the consolidation of the Big Five shipping shagaisen companies (Daido, Kawasaki, Kokusai, Mitsui, Yamashita) and the shasen (NYK and OSK) leading to war time control. At the time Japan launched the Pacific War, Japan had the world' third lagest merchant marines after Britain and the United States. It totaled some 6.3 million GRT and was about 8 percent biof thec world merchant tonnage. [Shindo] What the Japanese did not calculate as they prepared for war was the tremendious increase im merchant tonnage that the Pacific War would require, maintenence issues, or their ability to protect merchant shipping from the U.S. Pacific Fleet.

Inter-War Developments

American admirals accepted the Royal Navy assessment that the submarine would not play a major role in future wars because of the convoy system and ASDAC. The U.S, Navy thus largely abandoned the submarime as an important vessel type. With budgets cut to the bone after World War, there was little money available for an unimportnt vessel type. The experience of the S-20, that sank off Connecticut made headlines. largely because every man was saved thanks to the quick thinking of the captain. Early suns were still very dangerous, unforgiving vessels. Overlooking the smallest detail could lead to disaster. The crew had to perform with perfection. The S-20 crew neglcted to close the hatch that allowed air to the diesels before submerging. As a result the S-20 sank. The S-20 was not in deep water and the captain was a ble to use a hand drill to make a small hole in a portion of the sub still above the surface. He was able to wave a flag signling the need for help. It was only in the mid-1930s with the rising German and Japanese challenges, that more attention ws given to the submrine. Amother subarine, the Squalus off Portsmouth, New Hamshire. The circumstances were similar to the S-20. The Squalus sinking, however, resulted in a major effort to devlop safety technologies. And tham just n=months before Pearl Harbor, the United States began to launch thw mews Gato-class submrine (Auf=gust 1941). This provided the Pacific fleet large advanced fleet submarines which would play a key role in the Pacific War. They had long distance ranges and speed as well as offering the crews far greater creature comforts than the German U-bots or any other World War II submarines.

American Tactical Doctrine

The U.S. Navy's established tactical dioctrie for sunamrimes at the time of Pearl Harbor was tp accompany nattle squadrons, srving scout and screeminf functions and if possible fiosrupt eneny fleet formations,. possibly sinkking ships. A day after Pearl Harbor, however, Washington ordered the Pacific Fleet to commit its submarines to a campaigm of unrestricted submarine warfare agianst Japan. The German use of unrestricted submarine warfare was used by the British to paint the Germans as savage war criminals. This left the tactic of commerce raiding as a descredited measure. This depite the fact that the U.S. Navy was founded on commerce raiding. American naval doctrine was that submarines would serve as screens and scouts for the fleet. Submarine commanders were trained to be extremely cautious. The German successes in the North Atlantic during 1940 and 41 had no effect on American tactical doctrine for its submarines. No thought was given to using submarines as commerce raiders. This only came as a result of the prrceived violation of international norms in the attack and the fact tat bthe submarines were one of the few offensive weapons left to the Pacific fleet. The problem with this, however, was that 1) Amnerican submarine crews ommanders were not trained for this, 2) the commanders were not selected for their warrior spirit (like German abd Jaoanese commanders), 3) their boats had limited range in the vast Pacific, 4) they did not have radsr to help find the marus in the iceanic castness, and to make matters even wirse, 5) their roroedoes did not work. The Japanes aviatots whob attacked Pearl Harbor had such a low regard for submarinesm that the subs and their facilities were left untouched. Leaving them and the carrirts which were not at Pearl the Pacufic Fleets only offensive weapon. Despite all problens that had to be solved, the U.S. Navy would master all of these issues and turn the submarine force into the most effective weaapn in the Amnerican naval arsenal. By the end of the War they destouyed the Jaoamese maru flret and completely cut Japan off from the resources it had cionquered in Southeast Asia leaving ear olants ideled and its people near statvation.

Japanese Southern Resource Zone

Japan was Asia's first industrial power. Irionically it was an Asian country with very limited natural resources. Fom the onset of the Mejii Restoration, Japan aspired to emulate the European approach and seize a colonian empire to acquire the needed natural resources. The problem was that most of Asia except for China was already an European colonial possession. The major exception was China. So after seizing Formosa (Taiwan) and Korea, and Pacific islands, the Japanese went after China. China was militarily weak, but its emense size and stubborn resistwnce of its people prevented a total Japanese victory. And Japan rather than obtaining the raw matwrioals it needed found itself in need of more raw materials to continue the wae effort. After the out break of the War in Europe, the Strike North Faction gained suppot, but eventually collapsed and the Strike South Faction gained the accendency. Southeast Asia and the adjacent Dutch East Indies, offered Japan allthe resoitces it needed, but meant war with Britain and the Dutch. This was not a mjor impediment. The Dutch were weak militarily and occupied by the Germans. The British werrefully occupied in Europe and the North Atlantic. The United States was a very different matter. The Philippines had importnt resources, but could have been passed over, except for its location. The Philippines sat astride the sea lanes from the SRZ to Japan. The United States from the Philippines could have prevented the SRZ resources from reaching the Home Islands. Japan was almost totally dependant on imported oil, primarily from the United States which at the time was the leading producer. Japan imported about 90 percent of its oil. Japan had very limited oil fiekds and a small synthetic petroleum industry. And with an industrial economy and a large navy and merchant marine, Japan required large quantities of oil. The ongoing war in China also required oil. Japan's major source of oil was the United States. Before the invasion of China, Japan had been purchasing 80 percent of its oil in the United States (1937). The United States through its moral persuasion policy had suceeded in convincing American ship owners to reduce shipments to Japan without any formal action. Thus on the brink of war the Japanese were only obtaining 60 percent of theor oil in America (1941). The Japanese were importing American oil (along with Latin American and DEI oil) in Japanese and neutral country tankers. Oil was by far the most important product needed by the Japanese, but the SRZ offered much more, including rubber, nickel, tin, rice,and much more.

Unrestricted Submarine Warfare (December 1941)

The surprise Japanese carrier attack on Pearl Harbor changed every thing -- ushering the United States into the War Americans wanted to avoid. The Japandese nstantly changed a deeply divided nation desiring to stay out of the War, into a united nation resolutely determined to wage war with unprecedented force. This was important because the United States had an unparalleled capacity to wage war. It would take time to mobilize, but America had an industrial capability that no other country could come close to matching. Pearl Harbor has been discussed at length by countless authors. But one small detail rarely mentioned is that only 4 hours after the attack, Adm. Harold 'Betty' Stark, Chief of Naval Operations, sent a message to the Pacific Fleet orderung submariners to commence unrestricted submarine warfare--a fundanmental departure from existing U.S. Navy policy. In fact for more than two decades since World War I, unrestricted submarine warfare had been considered a war crime. President Roosevelt referred to U-boats as 'the rattle snakes of the Atlantic', because they had adopted unrestricted submarine warfare. As far as we know, Adm. Stark acted on his own obtained no authorization for this order from President Roosevelt. Adm. Stark was the naval commander responsible for carrying out the President's directives to aid Britain in the North Atlantic and finally launch an undeclared, and totally illegal naval war in the North Atlantic (September 1941). He thus knew more than anyone in Washingtin how devastating submarines could be. Adm. Stark could give the order, American submariners did not, however, have the training, doctrine, or weaponry (most importantly a torpedo that worked) needed to carry out that order. It would take nearly 2 years, but American submariners would eventually put Adm. Dönitz's vaunted U-boat men to shame--with few headlines becoming the most potent weapon in the Pacific Fleet's mighty arenal.

American Submarines

The Japanese at Pearl Harbor devestated the battleships of the Pacific Fleet. Undamaged was the submarine fleet. Thus the submarines were some of the few ships in 1942 that could take the war to the Japanese. The United States began the war with 51 submarines, 12 of which were still the old World War I era S-Class subs which proved unreliable in combat operations, even if the torpedoes functioned. Fortunately, 3 months before Pearl Hatbor, thev first of the new Gato-Class subs (312 feet) was launched (August 1941). The new Gato-class subs proved much more effective. They had everything the S-class subs lacked. American submarines had many advantages at the onset of the War. The first such advantage was a very effective combat command center which could very effectively plot out settings for torpedo attacks. The Torpedo Data Computer (TDC) was the early electro-mechanical analog computer used for submarine torpedo fire-control during World War II. It was the most advanced such system and constantly being upgraded during the War. The Germans had nothing to match it. The second advantage was the information available from code breaking. The third was effective radar which became available soon after the attack on Pearl Harbor and was significantly improved as the war oproigressed. Fourth was an extended range. The American submarines were superior to both German and Japanese subs.

Limited Effectiveness: Tactical Doctrine / Falty Topedoes (1942)

The Ameriican submarine campaign was hampered by two major problems: 1) poor strategic and tactical concepts and 2) ineffective torpedoes in 1942. American naval tactical doctrine was to use submarines as scouts and screening vessels. The idea of using submarines as commerce raiders was not adopted. In fact such usage was cinddered a war crime. As a result, sumarine captains were not trained to conduct ot tactiv=cal dictrine developed. The initial American submarine campaign was also hampered by ineffective torpedoes in 1942. Many mistakes were made by the American military in the years leasding up to the War. Perhaps the single most incopetent matter was the Navy's failure to develop an effective torpedo. The Navy developed a magnetically activated firing mechanism. Because of the cost, the Navy did not adequately test it topedoes and throughout 1942, American submaries were achieving hits but the torpedoes failed to explode. The trigger mechaism had faults and the Navy had not taken into account diffetrence in the earth's magnetic field. American submarines during 1942 averaged only about half a Japanese vessel sunk per mission during 1942. It took over a year to resolve the technical problems and effective torpedoes began to reach the American sunmarines. It was not until October 1943 that the American sunmarine campaign began to significantly affect the delivery of raw materials to Japan. The number of marus sunk began to reach sizeable numbers. American submatiners sank more than 600 Jaoanese ships (nearly 3 million tons) in 1944, more than 1941-43 combined.

Commerce War

American naval strategists saw the American submarine fleet as serving primarily as a part of fleet operations. The Imperial Navy had the same idea. Only slowly did the idea of commerce raiding become accepted. Like Britain, heavily populated and resource poor Japan was dependent on its sea lanes. The U.S. Navy subnmariners suceeded in the pacific while the Germans failed in the North Atlantic. Eventually the American submarines were used to target the Japanese merchant marine (maru) fleet. Tankers in particular were singled out. While the big fleet carriers got the headlines. The American submarines sunk over 50 percent of all vessels destroyed during the War. The Japanese merchant marine was almost completely destroying, cutting the country's war industries off from supplies and bringing the country close to starvation by 1945. The American submarines did to Japan what the German u-boats tried to do to Britain. The Japanese never develop the countrmeasures needed to adequately deal with the American submarines. The Japanese failed to develop a convoy system until late in the War and then it was not well implemented. One problem was that the Japanese did not have the technology to conduct sucessful anti-submarine warfare. The success of the american campaign was greatly aided by the fact that the American Navy by 1943 began to establish air and sea supperority in the South Pavific which it gradually extended northward towatd the Japanese home islands. The destruction of the Imperial fleet in 1943 and 44 greatly reduced the Japanese ability to protect sea commerce. Eventually 8.8 million tons of Japanese shipping was sunk in World War II. Over 60 percent of that total was lost to the American submarines.

Allied Pacific Naval Commands

The Commander in Chief, Pacific Fleet (CINCPACFLT) was Admiral Chester Nimitz. He was the primary American naval commander during the Pacific War, appointed by President Roosevelt almost immediately after the Pearl Harbor attack. He did not, howeverm, command all American Navy forces in the Pacific as the title rather suggests. The Commander Southwest Pacific (COMSOWESPAC) was General MacArthur. He controlled the 7th Fleet and other Naval assets, including submarines. American submarines in the Pacific were divided into two forces. Commander, Submarines, Pacific (COMSUBPAC) controlled the submarines operating from Pearl Harbor and subsequently other islands in the Central Pacific taken as the Americans rolled on toward Tokyo. The Commander, Submarines, South West Pacific (COMSUBSOWESPAC) controlled the subs operating out of Australia (Brisbane and Fremantle). This included the remnants of the Asiatic Fleet following the fall of the Philippines (April 1942). It was a multi-national force, including Dutch, Royal Navy, and Royal Australian Navy boats.

Commanders

American submarine commanders, once the topedo problem was fixed, proved to be very effective. While they get little publicity compared to the German U-boat commanders, they efficiently conducted the only major successful submarine campaign in history. Vice Admiral Charles Andrews Lockwood rrived to command the Submarine Force Pacific Fleet during World War II (January 1943). He devised tactics for the effective use of submarines, Hevturned a moribund force into a potent killing machgine. The Pacific Fleet submarins became man for man the Fleet's most effective fighting force, largely resonsivle for destroying the Japanese maru fllet, cripling ots war making capability. Perhaps the most famed American commander was Dudley 'Mush' Morton who commanded the fabeled Wahoo. He relentlessly sought out the Japanese and helped forge the way the Pacific Fleet subnmarine force waged the campaign. He was the first U.S. submariner to single-handely destroy an entire Japanese convoy. [Keith] We know very little at this time about Japanese commanders. They from the beginning of the War had an effective torpedo. They did not have the advantage of code breaking and radar that Americam commanders had. And the failure to wage an effective commerce war was in part due to decesions made by the Japanese High-Command as well as American ASW operations.

Wageing Submarine War

Serving on an Anerican Gato-class submarine was not easy duty. The Gato class subs marine formed the bulk of the American World War II submarine fleet. Conditions were better than aboard the German U-boats, but they were still very difficult and stressful. The Gatos had air conditioning--to prevent shir curcuits. But the crews benefiutted greatly. The food was great at first. But the fresh and frizen food was consumed in about 3 weeks after leaving Pearl and the other bases. This was the case in early in the War. As forward operational bases were won, this situation was somewhat improved. Unlike the larger ships of the U.S. Navy, there was little cold storage. The men had to rely on canned and dried foods. The crew had to stay below breathing stale air most if the time except while manning watches when the boat was running on the surface. There were long periods of no action puntuated by frightening combat. After a toroedo attack they might be subjected to a terrifying deth charge attack. Medical emergencies sych as appendetomies might be treated with kitchen utensils. Then there were desperate struggles to escape a sinking submarine. Some of the men were subjected to the horrors of a Japanese prison camps. [Scott]

Bases

The Pacific fleet's submarine force operated from two different bases. Before the War, they were Pearl Harbor and Cavite in the Philippines. The Japanese carrier attack on Pearl Harbor (December 7, 1941), and subsequent Pacific offensive, left the U.S. Navy with few operational bases in the western Pacific (December 1941). The loss of Subic Bay, Cavite, and other Philippines bases was especially harmful. Operating from bases in the Philippines, The Navy could have interdicted the sea lanes between the Home Islands and the Southern Resource Zone (SRZ). This left Pearl harbor as the Navy's forward operating zone. The loss of Singapore and the Dutch East Indies (DEI) left Australian bases, espeially Freemantle and Brisbane) as the other potential operating bases. Both were, however, at some distance to the Japanese sea lanes. Cavite had been an especially important sub base. A devestating Japanese air raid on the Cavite Naval Station south of Manila damaged USS Sealion (SS-195) beyond repair and destroyed the Cavite repair facility and most of the torpedoes stored there (December 10). Allied naval forces after a major defeat in the Java Sea, retreated to Australia (March 1942). American naval commanders decided to the U.S. high command decided to leave the remaining submarines of the Asiatic Fleet to operate out of Australian ports rather than joining the Pacific Fleet submarines at Pearl. They would they be in a good position there to attack Japanese sea lanes, especially oil tankers. The oil resources of the DEI and British Borneo were one of the principal reasons that the Japanese militarists launched the Pacific War. The Cavite subs were reassigned to Freemantle in Australia which was their operational base for the rest of the war. The Freemantle subs were ordered to operate in the South China Sea. MacArthur also controlled some subs operating out of Freemantle. They were at first given the added task of delivering supplies to the American and Filiipino guerillas and taking off American civilian who had managed to evade the Japanese. After Midway the Japanese naval superiority was substantially reduced (June 1942). This permited an American offensive beginning at Guadalcanal in the Solomons (August 1942). Soon offensives in South Pacific, especially New Guinea won sites for forward naval bases that could be used by both submarines and PT-boats. And offensives in the Central Pacific won additional forward operating bases. We note quite a number of forward bases for COMSUBSOWESPAC in the Solomons, the islands surrounding Rabaul, and along the New Guinea coast. These bases included support facilities for PT-boats and submarines. We are not sure yet to what extent the COMSUBSOWESPAC subs used these forward bases. The American sub base at Pearl was not damaged in the Japanse attack launching the War. The Japanese in the first two waves focused on the the air fields and capital ships, mostly battle ships as the carriers were not at Pearl when they attacked. Fortunately, Admiral Nagumo decided against a third strike which left the Pacific Flet's subs and principal base in tact. The Pearl COMSUBPAC subs operated in the East China Sea. As the war progressed, the Pearl subs were moved forward to the Marianas which meant that their combat missions were significantly shortened. Advances in the Central Pacific meant new sub bases for COMSUBPAC at Midway, Guam, and Saipan. These were important because sub operating from bases near the Japanese sea lanes effectively increased the striking power of American submarines.

Japanese Troop Deployments

The success of the American sunmarines was a factor in limiting the redeployment of the very substantial Japanese Army in China to man the Japanese Pacific bastions and the Philippines. [Parish] Put men and supplies on a Maru exposed them to American submarine attack. This was not a seriious problem in 1942, but the Ameriacn submarines began to bight in 1943 which was when the Japanesev needed to strengthen their bases in the southwest Pacific which were under increased Allied (American and Australian) attack. The American subs also made it difficult to supply the troops that were deployed to the Pacific. This was something that Imperial Hdeadquarters needed to consider as the power of the Imperial Fleet declined. Getting men on a Pacific island, was just part of the problem for the Japanese. They then had to be supplied. And on New Guinea and most small islands, local food was scarce or unavailable. Orders from Tokyo were 'self suffiency'. This essentially ordered many garrisons to starve.

Anti-submarine Warfare

As a result of the Battle of the Atlantic struggle against the German U-boats, America and Britain lainched a major scientific and technical effort to develop ASW technology even before Japan launched the Pacific War with the strike on Pearl Harbor. Major advances were achieved and by late-1942 had begun to reach the fleet. Here the greater scientific and industrial capacity of America and Britain were major factors. In contrast, the Japanese made little progress in developing effective ASW technologies despite the critical importance of protecting the Maru fleet. Japan was even more dependent on food abnd raw material imports than Britain. Not only did the Japanese not develop effective ASW technologies, but the sizeable naval and air losses as the war progressed, significally attrited the ASW capabilities that Japan had at the beginning of the War. This was primarily escort craft.

Covert Operations

The primary task assigned to American submariners was severing the Japanese sea lanes so that raw materals frpm the SRZ could not reach the armament factories on the Home Islands. This was, however, not the only roles assigned to the sub\mtiners. In addition to resucing downed irmen, submatrines were used for arange of covert opeations. They included supporting resistance groups, rescuing American and European civilians, and attacks on isolated Jopanese outposts. The idea was to avoid fire fights, but this was not always possible. One raider reports, "Immediately upon landing, a searchlight was turned on and something like a challenge shouted by someone on the beach with barking dogs. I had eased off the stern of the runner boat and was in water just above my knees. I assumed this was not a friendly spotlight. Fortunately, I had not been spotted and shot the searchlight out with a short burstof my BAR. A unifored Jap, judging from his seemingly wrapped leggings and cap, came charging at Gunner CarrinderHe came at full speed with rifle and fixed bayonet. Kahler was directly in front of me, about ten yards ahead, and Ed Heiz was about rge same distance on my right flant. With the searchlight out of commission, I shifted my position and directed my fireto take care of the Jap chrging Carrinder, who seemed to be close enough for hand-tohand combat. As I commenced firing I breathed a silent prayer that I wouldn't hit Gunner. I would be close and Carrinder was never the forgoing type. When I saw tracers from my fore tear in to enemy I felt relieved." [Monroe-Jones and Green]

Spyron Philippines Operations

With the exception of China, most of the areas occupied by the Japanese were Europen colonies. The Philippines was an American commonwealth, but about to be granted independence. Thus unlike the situation in Europe, these were not fertile grounds for building a resistance movemrnt. One exception was French Indochina. Here there ws not o much uppot for te Fench as opposition to the Japanese. Another exceoption was the Philippines. There was considerable support for the Americans in the Philippines, both because of the progressive American colonial administration and the upcoming granting of independence. As a result, a substantil resistance movement developed in the Philippines. MacArthur used some of the submarines based in Brisbane for supply and inteligence operations, but not to the exclusion of offensive submarine operations. Lt.Cmdr. Charles 'Chick' Parsons, a naval Reserve officer, was put in charge of the spy squadron (SpyRon). Parsons had managed a stevedore company in the Philippines unril the War. He was taken prisoner when Manila fell, put was repatriated because he was serving as Panamanian consul. The repatriation ship Gripsholm brought him to safety. He then joined the War and was inserted in the Philippines to organize, control, and supply resistance operations. SpyRon inserted 330 agents and landed 1,325 tons of supplies. The submarines in adiition to landing supplies brought 470 people to safety in Australia. There were 19 submariunes participoating in the Spyron missions, but most of the work was done by USS Narwhal, Uss Nautilus, and USS Stingray. [Jones and Nunan, p. 218.] By the time the Americans landed on Leyte, a force of 180,000 guerillas were active in the Philippones.

Small Craft Attacks

Submarines could strike without surfacing with torpedoes. Once the initial problems with American torpedoes were corrected, the submarines rapidly destroyed the Maru fleet. Torpedo attackse the safest way of sinking an enemy ship because it could be done without surfacing and exposing the submarine. This of course is why the Germans insisted in pursuing unrestricted submarine warfare in World War I. The American submariners by 1944, significantly reduced the number of large targets justifying a torpedo. And as operations shifted closer to the Home Islands, the targets increasingly became small ships. This required the submariners to surface abnd use the deck guns or even explosive charges. These targets wre sanpans, fushing boats, and other small craft. One author describes the attacks, ":For a submarine crew there was no maneuver more exhilerating, or more fear-inducing, than a surface gun action. Relying on surprise and speed, the submarine could suddenly punch through to the surface, while half-drenched sailors scrambled through the hatches to reach their guns and amunition lockers. A crack team aimed to get off the first shots within 20 seconds of surfacing. Men who were usually kept cramped beneath the sea were at last unleashed to encounter the enemy face tio face." [Sturma]

American Losses

The success of the American Pacific sunmarine campaign did not come without subtantial losses. The Navy lost 22 percent of its submarines deployed in the Pacific. This was the highest loss ratio experienced by any American combat operation during the War, although only a fraction of the losses experienced by the German U-boat and Japanese submarine fleets.

Table 1.--Japanese merchant marine shipping
sunk (1941-45).

Combat Groups Tons* Percentage
Submarines 4.9 million 54.6
Navy Carrier Air 1.5 million 16.3
Army Air 0.9 million 10.2
Navy Land Based Air 0.4 million 4.3
All Other Causes 1.3 million 14.5
Total 8.9 million 100 percent
*Tons sunk include only ocean going Marus (ships over
500 gross tons) sunk or disabled for the duration of the
war. Included are ships sunk by Allied submarines (2%),
by Allied aircraft (12%). 23% of those sunk during the
month of July 1945 were sunk by Allied carrier based
aircraft.
Source: William p. Gruner. "U.S. Pacific submarines in World
War II". (Historic Naval Ships Association: 2010).

Japanese Losses

The cost to American sunmarinrs was high. The Japanese paid, however, a much higher price than the American submariners. And the ships lost were never made up by increased production. The Japanese had a limited ship building capacity. And most of their shipyards received orders to build needed combat ships. American submarines in addition to hits on the combat vessels of the Imperial Fleet, essentially destroyed the Japanese Maru fleet. American submarines were the only effective weapon agaionst the Japanese Marus deeding the country's war economy during the first 2 years of the war [Gruner]. After 1943 with growing American air and naval power, other elements of U.S. forces began to contribute to the effort. All in all, Americann submtiners were responsible for sinking over half of the Maru fleet (table 1). The Japanese were left without any way of transporting the critical resources of the SRZ back to the factories on the Home Islands. Surviving Japanese war ships were in port without fuel and civilians were reduced to virtually starvation rations.

Sources

Gruner, William P. "U.S. Pacific submarines in World War II". (Historic Naval Ships Association: 2010).

Jones David and Peter Nunan. U.S. Subs Down Under: Brisbane, 1942-45 (Annapolis: Naval Institute Press, 2005).

Keith, Don. Undersea Warrior: The World War II Story of "Mush" Morton and the "USS Wahoo" (2011).

Kuroda, H. Sehai Kaiun Shi (Tokyo: Seizando, 1972).

McCormick, Harold A. "Japanese merchant marine," Proceedings Magazine Vol. 62 No.7/401 (July 1936).

Monroe-Jones, Edward and Michael Green. The Silent Service in World War II: The Story of the U.S. Navy Submarine Force in the Words of the Men Who Lived it (2012), 352p.

Parish, Thomas. The Submarine: A History (Viking, 2004), 576p.

Scott, James. The War Below: The Story of Three Submarines that Battled Japan (2013), 448p.

Shindo, Tadaaki. "A brief history of the Jaopanese merchant marine fleet," Keio Journal of Economics Vo. 75, No.? (February 1983), pp. 1034-55.

Sturma, Michael. Surface and Destroy: The Submarine Gun War in the Pacific, 280p.







CIH -- WW II







Navigate the CIH World War II Section:
[Return to Main World War II Pacific submarine campaign page]
[Biographies] [Campaigns] [Children] [Countries] [Deciding factors] [Diplomacy] [Geo-political crisis] [Economics] [Home front] [Intelligence]
[POWs] [Resistance] [Race] [Refugees] [Technology]
[Bibliographies] [Contributions] [FAQs] [Images] [Links] [Registration] [Tools]
[Return to Main World War II page]
[Return to Main war essay page]





Created: 5:51 AM 6/21/2004
Last updated: 6:50 AM 9/28/2020