Knee Pants: Popularity


Figure 1.--This cartoon by Neg Cockran appeared in many American newspapers as part of a synicated series called "Out Our Way" in 1968. It is a nostalgic look backward to an embarrassing moment in a boy's childhood and the American era of about 1912 or 1913 when knickers were rapidly replacing knee pants as standard wear for boys. Cartoons like this are interesting because they illustrate concerns of contemporary boys that are completely lost on modern boys.

Kneepants and knickers, or a least knee-lengthpants withblouced leg hems, appeared at about the same time. We note both being worn in the 1850s, but by the 1860s, kneepants were clearly more common. We are not sure why this was, but guess that straight-leg kneepants were easier to sew than blouse-leg pants. This continued until the early 20th century when more and more boys began wearing knickers. We are not sure as to how boys in the 1910s and 20s viewed the two styles. Although knickers were not a new style, clearly boys began seeing knickers as a more modern style. Interestingly some parents, especially in Europe, continued for some time to see kneepants as more appropriate for formal dresswear. We suspect that a major factor was that kneesocks rather than longstockings requiring a stocking supporter could be worn with knickers.

Boys' View

Kneepants and knickers, or a least knee-lengthpants withblouced leg hems, appeared at about the same time. We note both being worn in the 1850s, but by the 1860s, kneepants were clearly more common. We are not sure why this was, but guess that straight-leg kneepants were easier to sew than blouse-leg pants. This continued until the early 20th century when more and more boys began wearing knickers. We are not sure as to how boys in the 1910s and 20s viewed the two styles. Although knickers were not a new style, clearly boys began seeing knickers as a more modern style.

Parent's View

Interestingly some parents, especially in Europe, continued for some time to see kneepants as more appropriate for formal dresswear. We suspect that a major factor was that kneesocks rather than longstockings requiring a stocking supporter could be worn with knickers.

Winter Underwear

Although not common today, most children except in tropical countries, used to wear long winter underwear. This cartoon by Neg Cockran appeared in many American newspapers as part of a synicated series called "Out Our Way" in 1968. It is a nostalgic look backward to an embarrassing moment in a boy's childhood and the American era of about 1912 or 1913 when knickers were rapidly replacing knee pants as standard wear for boys. Cartoons like this are interesting because they illustrate concerns of contemporary boys that are completely lost on modern boys. The two boys who have already got their knickers are making fun of their friend who is still forced to wear knee pants. The boys with knickers buckle them below the knee (which is fairly advanced and daringly "modern") although they still wear long black stockings. The boy with the knee pants is embarrassed because his long-legged union suit shows between the tops of his stockings and the hem of his knee pants and you can also see that his stockings are being held up with hose supporters, probably attached to a waist. Notice the variety of hats the boys are wearing. The boys with knickers wear a stocking cap in one case and a flat cap of sorts in the other case, while the boy with the knee pants wears a more old-fashioned hat with a crown, a decorative band, and a small brim. Notice also the reference to the ritual of making boys wear long underwear during the cooler months. The boy with the "stovepipe" pants says that his mother doesn't want to buy him the new-style knickers while there is a still a few more months' wear in the knee pants. But his embarrassment will be a little less at this point, even if his mother won't buy him the new knickers which he would like, because at this time he will be allowed to switch from "longjohns" to summer underwear that won't show underneath the stockings. There is a fair amount of amusing social commentary about boys' clothing around 1910-1920 in this cartoon, which is quite revealing historically about boys' attitudes at the time. I wonder if the cartoonist, Cockran, is recalling a mortifying moment from his own boyhood.






HBC






Navigate the Boys' Historical Pants pages:
[Return to the Kneepants]
[Breeches] [Knickers] [Short pants] [Long pants]



Navigate the Boys' Historical Clothing Web Site:
[Introduction] [Activities] [Biographies] [Chronology] [Cloth and textiles] [Clothing styles] [Countries] [Topics]
[Bibliographies] [Contributions] [FAQs] [Glossaries] [Satellite sites] [Tools]
[Boys' Clothing Home]




Created: January 26, 2004
Last edited: January 26, 2004